Betting into an extremely liquid market such as NFL sides and totals is a very difficult endeavor. Lines move to efficiency very quickly and can’t be beaten at -110 by the overwhelming majority of bettors.
However, player props are more beatable. As hardcore fantasy players, we are actually putting more time and thought into player outlooks than the oddsmakers. And since the limits on these player props are typically low, many books don’t mind leaving up some soft lines. It’s essentially advertising to get people into their book. Don’t use player props as a guide for your DFS or season-long selections. Instead, we should be seeking out player props to bet.
Season-long player props are softer than weekly props. Books often don’t account for downside scenarios enough. In other words, over the course of a season, injuries, rest, and benchings all come into play. We can exploit that by leaning heavily toward unders.
The goal of this article isn’t to “tout” picks; it’s to help you develop your own process by showing you ours. You may not be able to get these lines at your book. The general idea is simple: Take a projection you’re confident in and compare it to the available line. After that, the key is to add in our knowledge of player usage to gain a bigger edge.
IMPORTANT: To get the best lines when we bet these, you must be subscribed to Draft Kit Pro AND be in our subscriber-only Discord with notifications set up correctly.
Levitan’s Published Player Prop History
2019 NFL In-Season Player Props: 50-36, +$963
2020 NFL In-Season Player Props: 55-34, +$1,907
2020-21 NBA In-Season Player Props: 111-82, +$1,817
2021 NFL In-Season Player Props: 216-118, +$8,572; 22.1% ROI
2021-22 NBA In-Season Player Props: 751-495, +$20,348; 14% ROI
2022-23 NFL In-Season Player Props: 308-222, +$5,860; 9.5% ROI
2022-23 NBA In-Season Player Props: 700-455, +$18,770; 13.9% ROI
2023-24 NFL In-Season Player Props: 253-225, +$267; 0.48% ROI
2023-24 NBA In-Season Player Props: 688-432, +$19,473; 14.73% ROI
2024-25 NFL In-Season Player Props Official Straight Bets: 228-158, +$5,969; 14.09% ROI
2024-25 NFL In-Season Player Props Official Alt/Longshot Bets: 38-222, +$736; 17.62% ROI
2024-25 NBA In-Season Player Props: 549-386, +$11,067; 10.13% ROI
2025-26 NFL In-Season Record: 203-164, +$2,405; 6.03% ROI
2025-26 NBA In-Season Record: 443-292, +$10,940; 12.74% ROI
* Won/lost dollar amount is based on betting to win $100 on each favored prop. And risking $100 on each underdog prop.
1. Jerry Jeudy receiving yards
Line: 624.5 yards
Book: DraftKings
Bet: Under (-110)
Date: August 11
Notes: Jeudy’s role is threatened by the additions of KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston, plus Cleveland’s QB room is a disaster.
We've created the best Draft Kit on the internet.
Our fantasy football Draft Kit Pro was created to prepare you with the highest-quality resources to help you win your league.
Our team of analysts, led by Evan Silva and Adam Levitan, create unmatched content and rankings to make sure you’re ready for draft day. While our Draft Kit is built for competitive fantasy players, we’ve made it fun and easy to consume.
If you aren’t satisfied with our Draft Kit for any reason, just email us within 48 hours of purchase and we’ll provide a full refund.
Full Draft Kit Overview » Already a subscriber? Log In
