Episode Summary: Man vs. Machine 2026 (August 14, 2026)
Adam Levitan hosts the annual Man vs. Machine debate, pitting Evan Silva’s personal Top-150 rankings against the projection-driven ETR ranks defended by Mike Leone. Silva is fading Justin Jefferson down to 16 overall because the Vikings’ QB battle is a real problem, while Leone has JJ at 8. Silva calls Brock Bowers a generational tight end at 13 overall, while Leone at 21 argues you are paying peak Travis Kelce prices for something Bowers has not shown. And Silva wants Kenneth Walker III at 9 overall as the Chiefs’ offensive focal point, while Leone at 14 says Walker is a riskier version of the James Cook/Derrick Henry bet. Plus 14 more debates on Kyle Pitts, Bucky Irving, Tee Higgins, Kyren Williams, A.J. Brown, Mike Evans, Luther Burden III, Trey McBride, Cam Skattebo, J.K. Dobbins, Quentin Johnston, Josh Downs, Juwan Johnson, and Patrick Mahomes.
Final score: Silva 8, Leone 9.
Listen to the Full Episode
Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube
Key Topics
- Silva more bullish than ETR (Silva ranks higher): Kyle Pitts (Silva 74 vs. ETR 98), Kenneth Walker III (9 vs. 14), Tee Higgins (25 vs. 40), Brock Bowers (13 vs. 21), J.K. Dobbins (62 vs. 90), Josh Downs (64 vs. 82), Luther Burden III (35 vs. 48), Mike Evans (34 vs. 52), Juwan Johnson (113 vs. 147), Quentin Johnston (72 vs. 85).
- Silva more bearish than ETR (Silva ranks lower): Justin Jefferson (Silva 16 vs. ETR 8), Bucky Irving (82 vs. 55), Kyren Williams (45 vs. 25), A.J. Brown (30 vs. 20), Trey McBride (39 vs. 28), Cam Skattebo (63 vs. 43), Patrick Mahomes (118 vs. 91).
Takeaway #1 (2:25): Silva is fading Justin Jefferson to 16 overall; ETR has him at 8 — Adam sides with Silva
- Evan Silva: It is at least a little worrisome that Kyler Murray could not shake J.J. McCarthy right away to begin Vikings camp. Murray has not been better than league average as a passer since 2021 and has never thrown for more than 26 touchdowns in a season. It is very much within the realm of possibility that McCarthy makes starts in the second half of this year. Justin Jefferson did not miss a single game last year and finished as the WR30. There are so many players Silva would rather take in the first round.
- Mike Leone: This is one of the better back-end first-round picks — it is not often you get a discount on an elite talent like this. Jefferson’s 17-game career averages are 105 catches, 1,534 yards, and eight touchdowns. Even going from McCarthy to a league-average version of Murray, Leone is ecstatic. Team pass volume should rebound in a big way, and we could very well see Jefferson go in the top three to five picks next year.
- Adam Levitan (ruling): Adam sides with Silva. There are so many good players to take in Round 1 — Amon-Ra St. Brown (very safe), Jonathan Taylor (very safe), CeeDee Lamb, James Cook, Saquon Barkley. If Jefferson is not a discount at No. 8 overall, then Silva’s tail-risk concern about McCarthy down the stretch is the tiebreaker. Silva wins.
Takeaway #2 (20:57): Silva has Brock Bowers as a first-round tight end at 13; ETR at 21 says the price is too steep — Adam sides with Leone
- Evan Silva: Silva’s bet is that Bowers is a generational talent. He is the only tight end in college football history to win the Mackey Award twice, both as an underclassman. As a rookie, he was third in the NFL in catches with 112 — the most for any rookie in league history regardless of position. He was a top-four tight end in fantasy points per game last year despite the PCL injury. Klint Kubiak just built the Seattle offense around Jaxon Smith-Njigba the same way, and Bowers will be Kubiak’s target-share fulcrum in Las Vegas.
- Mike Leone: The PCL injury holds guys back for multiple years, and this is Year 2 for Bowers. He is averaging about 15 fantasy points per game in half PPR. If you are taking him at the 1-2 turn, you need him to smash as the clear-cut TE1 by a margin. In 2020, Travis Kelce was not going this early despite averaging nearly 20 points per game and having back-to-back overall TE1 finishes. Add in Kirk Cousins at quarterback likely giving way to rookie Fernando Mendoza, and the historical data on rookie QBs and their pass catchers is not good.
- Adam Levitan (ruling): Both made strong arguments. Adam agrees more with the ETR rank on this one and gives it to Leone — the price at 13 requires elite wide receiver-level production Bowers has not yet shown, and the positional scarcity argument in a standard 12-team league gets softer when you consider you are starting three wide receivers where scarcity funnels down. Leone wins.
Takeaway #3 (14:57): Silva wants Kenneth Walker at No. 9 overall as the Chiefs’ offensive focal point; ETR at 14 says risky version of the James Cook/Derrick Henry bet — Adam sides with Silva
- Evan Silva: It makes all the sense in the world for the Chiefs to build their offense around Kenneth Walker III with Patrick Mahomes coming off ACL and LCL surgery. Mahomes admitted publicly he is not going to run this year, which opens up more dump-offs for Walker. The Chiefs gave Walker almost $15 million a year with $29 million guaranteed. Their top pass catchers are Travis Kelce (turns 37 a month into the season) and Rashee Rice (knee surgery in May, rehabbed in jail). Brandon Thorn has the Chiefs’ OL ranked eighth best in the league. Walker’s backups are Emari Demercado and rookie Emmett Johnson — almost no in-house competition.
- Mike Leone: Leone is not sure Walker is in the truly elite rushing category needed to justify a first-round pick. He is boom or bust with one of the poorer success rates in the NFL, especially by the goal line. Kansas City has used goal-line-specific backs before. Walker has never had a double-digit target share. He is essentially a riskier version of the James Cook or Derrick Henry bet, and we have more confidence in those two players, having done it before.
- Adam Levitan (ruling): Adam sides with Silva. Every defense plays Mahomes by dropping deep safeties to defend the pass. If they do that this year, Walker is going to go absolutely berserk against light boxes. The Chiefs have not had a running back capable of exploiting that in a long time. Kareem Hunt as a rookie was probably the last one. Silva wins.
Listen to the Full Episode
Spotify: Listen on Spotify
Apple Podcasts: Listen on Apple Podcasts
YouTube: Watch on YouTube
About Establish The Run
Establish The Run was founded by Adam Levitan and Evan Silva, two of the most respected analysts in fantasy football and sports betting. ETR delivers high-quality, actionable analysis across season-long, best ball, DFS, and props.
Join our Free Email List: Sign Up
Subscribe to ETR: Subscribe
